Here Comes a New Challenger! Another ‘trailblazer’ in the Miss Minnesota USA Pageant

Parallel to the Star Tribune‘s article on Halima Aden breaking ground by being the first contestant to wear a hijab and burkini in show [1], just three days ago the Star Tribune published an article mirroring the same language and pose concerning the Miss Minnesota pageant, but for a different trailblazer: a woman with Down syndrome [2]. I find it fascinating that both articles, while authored by different people, are titled by naming these women not with their given names but with their identities: “Somali-American teen” and “Woman with Down syndrome”. This is not the only rhetoric that marks both articles.

The rhetoric and symbolism of ‘first’ is prevalent within this article as well. “Mikayla [Holmgren] is a trailblazer,” who will be the “first woman with Down syndrome to compete in the state pageant, and as far as pageant officials know, the first in the country”. Similarly to Halima, “[h]er participation reflects the new strides toward body acceptance and more diverse beauty ideals that are being made not only in pageants, but on fashion runways and television.” Clearly, there is a lot at stake. People involved in the pageant even go so far as to say that “society’s traditional view of what’s beautiful is changing”.

Indeed, Mikayla recognizes the weight of her participation in this institution, saying that she hopes her presence will help to change the way society views disabilities and how we construct beauty. And yet, contrasted with this is a line from Mikayla’s mother about not wanting to be defined by Down syndrome and that label. In other words, much in the way that Vanessa Williams represented her race, regardless of whether she wanted to or not [3], Mikayla, too, represents those with Down syndrome—and perhaps even more broadly, those with disabilities.

Interestingly, the article begins immediately with:

When Mikayla Holmgren applied for the Miss Minnesota USA pageant, she submitted a lengthy résumé that highlighted her past pageant experience, her status as a triple-threat athlete and her work as a mentor for other young women like her.

While I admittedly know relatively little about what it takes to be a contestant in a pageant, the language of “lengthy résumé” and “triple-threat” struck me as a sign of how Mikayla would have to work much harder than the average applicant to be considered of equal standing—much like the women of color in pageants, as reflected in the lack of black Miss Americas despite being nominally race-neutral, objective, or colorblind.

Much the opposite, according to Wallace, executive co-director of the Miss Minnesota USA pageant; they have always valued inclusion and diversity and “what is amazing and beautiful about this [Mikayla’s presence] is the fact that women are finally seeing representations of themselves in this capacity”. However, I think similar questions can be asked of this situation as of Halima’s and of Vanessa Williams’s: Is Mikayla’s mere presence enough, or is the symbolic victory of becoming Miss Minnesota or Miss America necessary for Wallace’s statement to be true? Even if Mikayla does go far in the pageant, can one person really “represent” such heterogeneous groups as people with Down syndrome or people who are differently-abled? How much will Mikayla’s presence be a show of symbolic progressivism? It will be interesting to observe the rhetoric of the media come November when Mikayla participates in full.

Notes

[1] Liz Sawyer, “Somali-American teen makes semifinals at Miss Minnesota USA pageant,” Star TribuneNovember 28, 2016, http://www.startribune.com/somali-american-teen-makes-semifinals-at-miss-minnesota-usa-pageant/403288226/

[2] Aimee Blanchette, “Woman with Down syndrome to compete in Miss Minnesota USA pageant,” Star TribuneApril 22, 2017, http://www.startribune.com/first-woman-with-down-syndrome-to-compete-in-miss-minnesota-usa-pageant/420145783/

[3] Sarah Banet-Weiser, The Most Beautiful Girl in the World: Beauty Pageants and National Identity (Los Angeles, CA: University of California Press, 1999).

Advertisements

One thought on “Here Comes a New Challenger! Another ‘trailblazer’ in the Miss Minnesota USA Pageant

Add yours

  1. I definitely agree with esoterick that the positioning of Mikayla and Halimas’ inclusion in the Miss Minnesota pageant seems to tokenize them as representatives of marginalized groups. And I am also interested in the rhetoric around their participation both in the language of overcoming obstacles and of firsts.
    What immediately strikes me about Mikayla is that she does embody the Western standard of feminine beauty: she is white with long blonde hair, light eyes, and a thin body. It seems that her looks may give her an advantage in “overcoming” the barriers against people with disabilities.[1] Mikayla was crowned junior Minnesota Miss Amazing in 2015, which is a pageant specifically for girls and women with disabilities. The article quotes the director of Miss Amazing saying, “We’re stepping away from the ‘Miss Congeniality’ vibe where everyone has blond hair and blue eyes. That’s not what we accept or define as beauty anymore.”[2] This quote in conjunction with Mikayla’s appearance is an interesting choice. And the fact that Mikayla won the pageant seems to suggest that while Miss Amazing may be attempting to “step away” from traditional beauty norms, the pageant still perpetuates the very norms it seeks to disrupt. The “managerial democracy” moderation of diversity and difference, “within terms bounded and determined by tropes of whiteness” described by Sarah Banet-Weiser is alive and well in the pageant world. [3] As with many of the African American winners of Miss America, such as Vanessa Williams, who still embody white-defined beauty characteristics, Mikayla seems to fit the traditional Western beauty mold in most ways.

    Notes
    [1] Aimee Blanchette, “Woman with Down syndrome to compete in Miss Minnesota USA pageant,” Star Tribune, April 22, 2017, http://www.startribune.com/first-woman-with-down-syndrome-to-compete-in-miss-minnesota-usa-pageant/420145783/.
    [2] Aimee Blanchette, “Woman with Down syndrome to compete in Miss Minnesota USA pageant.”
    [3] Sarah Banet-Weiser, The Most Beautiful Girl in the World: Beauty Pageants and National Identity (Los Angeles, CA: University of California Press, 1999), 128.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: